Procreate vs a stencil app: trace by hand or go automatic?
Hand tracing in a drawing app and generating a stencil automatically are not rivals. They solve different parts of the job. Here is what each does well, where each falls down, and the hybrid workflow most working artists settle on.
Updated 17 November 2026
Tracing by hand in Procreate (or any drawing app)
The classic method: put the reference on a bottom layer, lower its opacity to 20–40%, add a new layer on top, and trace with a monoline or technical pen brush. Hide the reference, export the line layer, and print.
Where it wins
- Every line is a decision. You choose what to include, simplify and exaggerate. For a custom design, that judgement is the design.
- Redrawing, not copying. You can fix proportions, straighten a shaky photo, merge two references or change a pose while tracing.
- Lettering and geometric work. Script, mandalas and ornamental pieces need deliberate curves and symmetry that edge detection cannot invent.
- Learning. For apprentices, tracing teaches which lines matter. That skill transfers to freehand and to fixing any stencil.
Where it costs you
- Time. A simple flash piece takes 10–20 minutes; a detailed portrait outline often 45–90 minutes. Across a week of consultations, that adds up.
- Size is manual. You have to set canvas dimensions and dpi correctly, then make sure the print path does not rescale. Many “wrong size” stencils start here; see printing at actual size.
- Hardware. It needs a tablet and pencil, and the file still has to reach the printer.
Automatic stencil makers
An automatic stencil maker finds edges in the reference and turns them into clean black lines. In StencilReady you choose a style (Outline, Sketch or Solid), adjust detail, sensitivity and line weight, and print at true size, usually within a minute.
Where it wins
- Speed. A first version in seconds, so you can show the client a stencil during the consultation.
- Faithful shapes. For realism and portraits, the software follows the reference's contours and shadow edges precisely. Proportions do not drift the way a quick trace can.
- Size and output handled. Size in cm or inches, pure black lines, mirror control and a calibration ruler come with it.
- Repeat work. Flash sheets, matching tattoos and walk-in designs at several sizes take minutes instead of an evening.
Where it falls short
- It cannot design. It traces what is there. It will not fix a bad pose or redraw a hand.
- It does not know what matters. A strong shadow on a cheek and a crease in a T-shirt look the same to an edge detector. You still decide what stays.
- Weak references give weak stencils. Blurry, dark or low-contrast photos give broken lines.
- Lettering and symmetry. Generated lines follow the reference, imperfections included.
Which to use when
| Job | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Portrait or realism outline from a good photo | Automatic, then touch up |
| Pet portrait | Automatic, then touch up |
| Client's pencil sketch or a drawing you made on paper | Automatic (Solid style cleans up a photo of a drawing) |
| Flash, existing line art | Automatic |
| Script and lettering | By hand |
| Mandala, geometric, ornamental | By hand |
| Custom design combining several references | By hand, or automatic for each part then compose |
| Silhouette or blackwork shape | Automatic (Solid style) |
The hybrid workflow
For most pieces, the fastest route to a stencil you trust is: generate, then edit.
- Generate the base. Load the reference in StencilReady. Pick a style, keep detail on the low side, and set the real size and line weight. Turn on clean up stray marks.
- Export a PNG. Download it at the size you set. Pro exports at 300 dpi, which gives you more pixels to edit.
- Touch up in your drawing app. Import the PNG to a new canvas. Put the original reference underneath at low opacity. Erase lines that do not belong (clothing folds, background, hair strands) and redraw the few that matter most: eyes, lips, the main contour. Close any gaps in the outline.
- Keep the size. Do not resize or crop the canvas once the PNG is in, or note the new dimensions. Export at the same resolution.
- Print at 100%. Print with no scaling and check the size against a ruler. If you print from StencilReady's PDF, the sheet has a calibration ruler; if you print your edited PNG from another app, measure a known dimension of the design.
A ten-minute touch-up on a generated base usually beats an hour of tracing from scratch, and your judgement still decides every line that matters.
Settings that make touch-up easier
- Lower detail. Adding three lines by hand is quicker than erasing thirty.
- Outline style for redrawing. Even lines are easier to match with a monoline brush than the varied weight of Sketch.
- Remove plain background before generating, so you do not erase the edge of the photo.
- Check in the on-skin preview before exporting. Clutter is easier to see in violet than in black.
For portrait-specific choices see portrait stencils from a photo, and for weights see line weight and needle size.